Apple needs all four of its iPhones to be popular if it's going to reignite sales

One of the archetypal things Steve Jobs did erstwhile helium returned to Apple successful 1997 was simplify Apple's merchandise lineup. At the clip that meant 4 computers: Two laptops and 2 desktops, each successful a pro and user version. 

"If we had 4 large products, that's each we need," Jobs said astatine a merchandise motorboat successful 1998.

Three decades later, Apple's merchandise lineup is overmuch broader. The institution successful 2024 launched four iPads, 4 MacBooks, 2 desktop Macs, 1 Vision Pro headset, 2 Apple Watch models and 3 kinds of AirPods. But erstwhile it comes to iPhones, 4 remains the magic number. 

That's however galore iPhones the institution has released each twelvemonth since 2020, and successful September, it released the iPhone 16, the iPhone 16 Plus, the iPhone 16 Pro and the iPhone 16 Pro Max.

Apple introduced the four-phone lineup due to the fact that historically the company's iPhone income person seen the strongest maturation erstwhile it expanded the lineup. If Apple tin amusement maturation from the 4 caller phones it releases each twelvemonth without them cannibalizing 1 another, that gives the institution its champion accidental to spot iPhone income turn meaningfully for the archetypal clip since 2022.

The institution doesn't springiness income figures for its idiosyncratic products, and wide iPhone income for fiscal 2024 came successful astatine $201.18 billion. That's comparatively level going backmost to 2022. 

Unfortunately for Jobs' company, not each of the iPhones are arsenic popular. 

Every twelvemonth since 2020, 1 of the caller iPhone models has lagged its siblings successful sales. This twelvemonth it's the iPhone 16 Plus, which lands successful the mediate of the lineup. At $899 successful the U.S., it's much costly than the baseline iPhone 16 but cheaper than the iPhone 16 Pro and Pro Max, which person amended screens.

DSCC, a probe steadfast focused connected the smartphone show manufacture with estimates derived from the sheet proviso chain, has picked up connected this trend. The shares of the Pro and Pro Max phones person been rising connected an yearly ground portion the Plus exemplary declined from astir 21% of full Apple surface orders successful 2022 to 10% successful 2023, according to DSCC's information for yearly sheet procurement done October. While it recovered somewhat to 16% this year, it's inactive the lowest measurement retired of the company's caller iPhones, according to DSCC.

"They're inactive truly struggling with this 4th model," DSCC laminitis Ross Young said.

Other information shows the Plus lagging, too. The iPhone 16 Plus accounted for 4% of wide iPhone income successful the U.S. successful the 3rd 4th portion some the Pro and Pro Max each accounted for 6% of sales, according to survey findings by Consumer Intelligence Research Partners. The regular 16 accounted for 4%, too, though aboriginal rhythm iPhone income are heavy weighted toward aboriginal adopters and the Pro models, according to CIRP.

The metric lone includes a fewer weeks of the latest exemplary income successful the 3rd quarter, but the 2024 findings are successful enactment with past year's, wherever the 15 Plus accounted for 3% of full income astir a period aft launch.

Apple's iPhone 15, iPhone 15 Pro and iPhone 15 Pro Max took the apical 3 spots, respectively, successful Counterpoint's information for the best-selling idiosyncratic smartphone models astir the satellite successful the 3rd 4th of 2024. The Plus exemplary didn't marque the apical 10 list.

When the iPhone was introduced successful 2007 determination was 1 caller exemplary per year. The lineup has expanded rather a spot since then, portion Apple keeps older models connected store shelves arsenic fund options.

In 2014, Apple introduced the iPhone 6 Plus, the archetypal clip iPhone came successful 2 sizes, which led to 3 consecutive quarters of maturation of implicit 27% successful 2015. After Apple released the iPhone X successful 2017, raising the terms of the highest-end telephone and creating a three-model lineup, the institution saw 3 consecutive quarters of maturation of much than 15%.

After Apple moved to a four-phone lineup successful 2020, maturation surged, hitting 54% successful 1 quarter, though that was partially boosted by the pandemic. But since then, iPhone income person been fundamentally flat.

When the institution introduced the iPhone Mini successful 2020, it was the lowest-cost caller iPhone astatine the time, astatine $699. 

Apple kept the aforesaid strategy successful spot successful 2021, hoping that the vocal number of consumers that had antecedently demanded smaller phones would flock to the device. It didn't work, and Apple nary longer sells a instrumentality with a 5.4-inch screen.

By 2022, Apple shifted its attack and introduced the iPhone 14 Plus, which had the aforesaid spot and features arsenic the company's introduction level iPhone 14 but a larger screen. That mirrored Apple's palmy strategy from 2014. Apple boosted its sheet procurement for the iPhone 14 Plus up to 21% of the full screens it ordered that cycle, according to DSCC.

But the Plus strategy didn't enactment arsenic good arsenic it had before. 

Looking ahead, Apple is keeping its 4 iPhones strategy successful place, but it whitethorn alteration the attack it takes to uncovering a palmy 4th exemplary for its 2025 lineup.

Instead of a 4th Mini exemplary astatine the debased extremity of the lineup oregon a Plus successful the middle, Apple whitethorn present an Air exemplary astatine the apical of the lineup. An Air offering could beryllium distinguished by a lighter-weight instrumentality and a higher starting price, according to an August study by Bloomberg News.

Despite giving it a higher terms tag, Apple whitethorn person to marque a trade-off connected the Air instrumentality by limiting it to 1 camera, owed to the lighter value and a slimmer design. Apple's existent high-end phones, the Pro and Pro Max, person 3 large cameras that adhd photographic capabilities but besides adhd weight. DSCC's Young said helium expects the surface size of the Air to travel successful astatine 6.55 inches, betwixt this year's Pro and Pro Max sizes.

A caller high-end telephone could marque consciousness for Apple. In caller years, the Max models person outperformed the lower-end models successful sales, suggesting determination is stronger request for much almighty and feature-packed phones astatine the apical of Apple's lineup than determination is for lower-cost models.

In October, Apple signaled that the institution had capable banal of the iPhone 16 and iPhone 16 Plus to conscionable request but that the much costly Pro and Pro Max were inactive successful abbreviated supply.

Outside the U.S., Apple's much costly models person shown much maturation successful caller years. In the archetypal 3 weeks of iPhone 16 income successful China, the 16 Pro and Pro Max models were up 44% compared with past year's high-end models.

Model preferences besides alteration crossed regions, Counterpoint expert Varun Mishra told CNBC.

"In China, the Pro bid is performing well, arsenic consumers determination thin to favour the Pro models," Mishra said successful an email. "In India, the Pro bid is strong, partially owed to a little motorboat terms compared to past year, acknowledgment to section manufacturing."

Apple has antecedently released thinner, lighter models of its existing products successful bid to rise prices and propulsion the limits of its engineering. In 2008, Apple introduced the MacBook Air, which it marketed by saying that it was bladed capable to acceptable successful an envelope. At first, it was much costly than Apple's different Macs, starting astatine $1,799, but implicit the years, MacBook Air has go Apple's entry-level laptop.

In 2013, the institution did the aforesaid happening with its iPad, introducing an iPad Air, with a thinner design, though it was Apple's flagship caller iPad exemplary released that year. Apple present uses the iPad Air arsenic the mediate enactment successful its iPad lineup.

For Apple, a displacement from Plus to Air could mean much iPhone sales, particularly if the caller exemplary is priced higher than the different iPhones, which could assistance Apple grow its borderline and proceed the caller inclination of a higher mean iPhone selling price. It could besides assistance absorption Apple's aboriginal adopters and fans connected 1 azygous high-end iPhone model.

"Next twelvemonth they're going to effort thing different," Young said.

WATCH: The iPhone 16 upgrade tin beryllium a multiyear cycle, says BofA's Wamsi Mohan