As Israel struck Qatar, South Africans saw echo of last decade of apartheid

Cape Town, South Africa – Gonda Perez remembers the time South Africa’s apartheid authorities bombed a exile campy successful the Zambian capital, Lusaka, during an aerial raid.

It was successful the mid-1980s. Perez was moving arsenic a dentist astatine a section infirmary astatine the clip and saw astir 10 victims brought successful connected trucks serving arsenic makeshift ambulances. One of the victims is etched successful her memory.

Recommended Stories

• list 1 of 3The South African anti-apartheid cathedral that’s present a pro-Palestine hub
• list 2 of 3Israel attacks Qatar: What’s next?
• list 3 of 3Arab states reconsider “normalisation deals with Israel”

“I stood successful casualty, and I watched radical travel successful with wounds, horrible wounds,” said Perez, present 69. “One antheral that I retrieve had humor spurting … truthful evidently it deed an artery oregon thing retired of his back… There was humor each implicit the amusement and it was truly horrible to look at.”

That day, Perez said, the South African Defence Force (SADF) had meant to onslaught members of Umkhonto we Sizwe (MK), the subject helping of the African National Congress (ANC), which led the conflict to extremity racist achromatic number regularisation successful South Africa successful 1994. But they deed civilians instead.

Perez, who was an ANC subordinate surviving successful exile aft fleeing South Africa successful the 1970s owed to her governmental activities, witnessed respective SADF bombings and raids crossed respective determination countries astatine the time.

She says the Lusaka raid was 1 of galore specified “mistakes” committed by the apartheid service owed to faulty intelligence. For her – and galore observers posting connected societal media – those bombings besides person shades of the Israeli military’s attack connected Qatar past week, which aimed to deed the enactment of Palestinian radical Hamas, among them elder leaders Khalil al-Hayya and Khaled Meshaal.

Instead, it killed al-Hayya’s son, Humam, arsenic good arsenic an aide, 3 bodyguards, and a Qatari information officer, successful a residential suburb successful Doha that is besides location to embassies, schools and supermarkets.

The onslaught came astatine a clip erstwhile Qatari officials, who are cardinal mediators successful talks betwixt Israel and Hamas, had been trying to broker a ceasefire successful Gaza, wherever Israel has killed much than 64,000 radical since launching its warfare connected the Palestinian enclave 2 years ago. A United Nations inquiry and starring scholars person declared the killings successful Gaza a genocide.

Israel’s concern of the West Bank has besides go progressively violent, and it has launched attacks connected neighbouring countries, citing assorted threats. Over a 72-hour play this month, Israel struck Palestine, Yemen, Syria, Lebanon, Tunisia and Qatar.

This subject escalation is reminiscent of the brutal assaults the apartheid authorities launched connected its neighbours successful the decennary oregon so before its demise, analysts note, arsenic it attacked countries including Zambia, Angola, Namibia, Zimbabwe, Botswana and Mozambique. Like Israel today, apartheid South Africa justified its incursions arsenic indispensable to combat its “terrorist” enemies, a assertion which helped some countries triumph enactment from the United States.

“Similar to Israel’s caller actions, South Africa’s subject enactment overseas relied connected targeted attacks against ANC enactment and safehouses, arsenic good arsenic different activists,” said Sonja Theron, a lecturer successful information studies astatine the University of Pretoria. Apartheid assassinations included shootings and bombings, with civilians often caught successful the crossfire.

“The disregard for planetary law, peculiarly sovereignty, is besides similar,” Theron noted.

Over the past 2 years, Israel has struck and killed Hamas members successful Iran and Lebanon, portion its subject besides bombs sites associated with Hezbollah and Yemen’s Houthis, groups it says it targets for their enactment of Hamas. Civilians person besides been killed successful these attacks. 

Similarly, apartheid South Africa’s cross-border attacks aimed to neutralise the MK and different determination liberation organisations which were granted refuge and enactment by the “front-line states”, a escaped conjugation of African countries committed to ending apartheid and achromatic number rule.

An ‘intimate’ connection

Observers enactment that the parallels betwixt Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s authorities successful Israel and the apartheid authorities are acold from coincidental.

Apartheid was officially instituted successful South Africa successful 1948, the aforesaid twelvemonth the authorities of Israel was born. Both nations utilized spiritual justification to beforehand an ethnonationalist ideology, and some defined themselves by their conflict against a akin enemy, with the apartheid National Party and the Zionist authorities viewing themselves arsenic an oasis of Western civilisation surrounded by hostile autochthonal peoples, researchers say.

In his 2023 book, The Palestine Laboratory, autarkic writer Antony Loewenstein writes that aft South African Prime Minister John Vorster, a Nazi sympathiser, visited Israel successful 1976, the authorities yearbook carried the pursuing message: “Israel and South Africa person 1 happening supra each other successful common: they are some situated successful a predominantly hostile satellite inhabited by acheronian peoples.”

These affinities resulted successful a choky confederation built astir defence, with mineral-rich South Africa supplying the superior and Israel the technology.

The Jewish colony of Pisgat Ze’ev is disposable down a conception of Israel’s separation barrier, arsenic roadworthy signs constituent to the Palestinian towns of Jericho, Ramallah, and Hizma, successful the occupied West Bank colony of Hizma, adjacent Jerusalem, successful 2005. Israel took inspiration from apartheid South Africa’s radical segregation policies [File: Muhammed Muheisen/AP]

But Israel besides took inspiration from South Africa’s harsh radical segregation policies, successful peculiar the “Bantustan” reserves that forced Black South Africans into “homelands”. These taste states served arsenic the blueprint for the 165 “enclaves” Israel established successful the occupied West Bank, cutting up Palestinian land, according to Loewenstein.

At the bosom of the narration were weapons, though. Loewenstein writes that South Africa and Israel signed a concealed information statement successful April 1975, which laid the instauration of their narration for 2 decades.

Loewenstein quotes Alon Liel, a erstwhile Israeli ambassador to Pretoria successful the 1980s: “After 1976, determination was a emotion matter betwixt the information establishments of the 2 countries and their armies. We were progressive successful Angola arsenic consultants to the army. You had Israeli officers determination cooperating with the army. The nexus was precise intimate.”

So intimate, successful fact, that Israel contravened United Nations Security Council sanctions imposed connected apartheid South Africa, portion besides furthering concealed practice astir gathering atomic capabilities. Loewenstein reveals that South Africa reportedly adjacent allowed Israel to trial atomic weapons successful the Indian Ocean successful 1979, which Israel denies.

Emboldened by its modern weaponry, South Africa launched its bid of wars successful determination countries successful the 1970s and 1980s. In galore ways, the swirl of battles successful the front-line states backmost past was a proxy for the broader Cold War standoff.

Civil wars were raging successful Angola and Mozambique pursuing their independency from Portugal, with Angolan MPLA authorities forces backed by Cuba and the Soviet Union warring against UNITA rebels backed by Pretoria and the US. In Mozambique, the ruling FRELIMO – which was backing liberation movements successful the portion – fought RENAMO, a radical supported by apartheid South Africa and the achromatic minority-led Rhodesia (which became Zimbabwe successful 1980 pursuing independence). Meanwhile, Namibia’s South West Africa People’s Organisation (SWAPO) was engaged successful an independency warfare with South Africa.

An estimated 1.5 cardinal radical died betwixt 1980 and 1988 arsenic a effect of deaths from nonstop conflict, disease, famine and disruptions successful wellness services. Angola and Mozambique, wherever South Africa had backed rebels to combat against pro-democracy liberators, bore the brunt of the conflict.

The economical outgo of the demolition of infrastructure, overmuch of it owed to South African aggression, exceeded $60bn implicit this period.

Gravely wounded Albie Sachs, a salient South African lawyer and anti-apartheid activistic surviving successful Mozambique, tried to assistance himself from the pavement successful Maputo, connected April 7, 1988, aft helium was injured successful an detonation by South Africa’s apartheid authorities [File: AP Photo/AIM News Agency]

‘Increasingly unpopular, politically costly’

After decades of apartheid regularisation and determination tensions, analysts accidental the goodwill of different liberation movements successful Southern Africa towards the ANC was wearing thin, arsenic South Africa’s subject and economical prowess exhausted its smaller rivals.

But astatine the aforesaid time, Pretoria was drafting expanding planetary condemnation arsenic its brutal conflicts overseas and its crackdown connected civilian uprisings astatine location became indefensible, resulting successful US sanctions via the Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act successful 1986.

For galore observers, this outrage mirrors the increasing absorption to Israel, particularly arsenic images look regular of Palestinians successful Gaza killed by Israeli bombs oregon starved due to the fact that of nutrient supplies being blocked.

Last Tuesday’s onslaught connected Doha besides appeared to deepen planetary absorption to Israel’s progressively combative actions. Even accepted Israeli allies joined successful the criticism, including Germany and the US.

At the aforesaid time, Spain and the European Union announced a series of measures against Israel, including an arms embargo, sanctions connected “extremist Israeli ministers” and settlers, and a suspension of bilateral support.

“The United States’ narration with apartheid South Africa perpetually varied considerably depending connected the administration, with the policies of Nixon, Ford, Carter, and Reagan differing successful meaningful ways. We spot akin geopolitical developments perpetually changing the playing tract erstwhile it comes to Israel and Palestine,” said Lazlo Passemiers, a historiographer based astatine the University of the Free State successful South Africa.

“What tin beryllium said with greater certainty is that Israel’s continued reliance connected subject aggression crossed the region, and its acts of genocide successful Gaza, are making it progressively unpopular and politically costly for different countries to supply it with unfastened support.”

Qatar’s Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman bin Jassim Al Thani has called for a collective response to Israel’s onslaught connected Qatar, informing that “the full Gulf portion is astatine risk.”

However, experts constituent retired that contempt the disapproval of Israel’s actions, Netanyahu is improbable to backmost down from his subject ambitions arsenic agelong arsenic helium enjoys the enactment of President Donald Trump’s authorities successful Washington.

US Secretary of State Henry Kissinger chats with RF Botha, South African Ambassador to the United States astatine Andrews Air Force Base successful Maryland, connected September 13, 1976 [File: Charles Tasnadi/AP]

The cardinal quality betwixt Israel present and South Africa then, according to analysts, is that Israel is of acold greater strategical worth to the US than South Africa was during the Cold War era, and truthful enjoys astir unlimited enactment from the world’s superpower.

Furthermore, the US’s determination to enforce sanctions connected South Africa successful the 1980s required bipartisan compromise to overturn President Ronald Reagan’s veto of the measure – a script which is improbable successful the sharply divided governmental clime that presently prevails successful the US.

Demand alteration ‘from wrong Israel’

In the antiauthoritarian era, South Africa’s ruling ANC has been fiercely pro-Palestine since its archetypal electoral triumph successful 1994. By asserting its enactment for Palestine, President Cyril Ramaphosa, arsenic the existent caput of the ANC, has continued a agelong bequest of collaboration.

Shortly aft his merchandise from situation successful 1990, Nelson Mandela made it wide that the ANC had nary plans to region itself from the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) oregon the Palestinian origin arsenic a whole, contempt the PLO being labelled a “terrorist” organisation by the US and Israel. The ANC has maintained its enactment for Palestinian independency ever since.

In 2018, South Africa withdrew its ambassador from Israel aft the Israeli service killed dozens of peaceful protesters successful Gaza, and successful 2021, it campaigned against Israel being granted perceiver presumption successful the African Union.

In December 2023, Ramaphosa’s medication lodged a case with the International Court of Justice (ICJ), accusing Israel of genocide successful Gaza. The country’s parliament has besides voted for cutting each ties with Israel, though the authorities has not followed done connected that call.

Despite disapproval from activists that it is not doing capable to clasp Israel accountable, the South Africans importune the ICJ lawsuit is the optimal transmission to registry their protest.

Meanwhile, arsenic the onslaught connected Qatar leaves the imaginable of a bid woody betwixt Israel and Hamas successful tatters, analysts accidental the champion anticipation of bringing the 2 sides unneurotic could prevarication successful the South African example.

The large acquisition from the downfall of apartheid was that it relied connected some outer unit – including boycotts, sanctions, enactment for liberation movements, and planetary absorption to Pretoria – arsenic good arsenic home pushback, analysts said.

“Demands for alteration from wrong Israel volition beryllium indispensable to bring astir an extremity to Israel’s oppression and violence,” said Theron.

South African anti-apartheid person Nelson Mandela meets with Palestinian Liberation Organisation Chairman Yasser Arafat, connected May 20, 1990 successful Cairo, Egypt [File: Axel Schulz-Eppers/AP]

Meanwhile, for Perez, watching the warfare unfold successful Gaza has triggered memories of her ain trauma during the anti-apartheid struggle.

She recalls the changeless raids crossed the borderline into Botswana to abduct anti-apartheid fighters surviving there, a missive weaponry ripping disconnected the manus of a young comrade successful Zambia, and the respective times she had to relocate to flight apartheid forces, often crawling on the crushed arsenic she made her getaway.

However, she says what’s happening successful Gaza is simply a acold outcry from her idiosyncratic ordeal, and it’s thing she hopes Israel tin beryllium held accountable for.

South Africa indispensable bash more, Perez feels, including cutting disconnected each commercialized relations with Israel and lobbying to person it kicked retired of planetary bodies similar the shot federation FIFA and the Olympics.

“We request to throttle them economically with sanctions [as was done to apartheid South Africa], and past we volition scope that constituent wherever Israel volition beryllium forced to travel and negociate and beryllium forced to see a escaped Palestine,” she said.

“There’s a batch much enactment to beryllium done.”