Bolsonaro verdict likely: What to expect in Brazil, and from Trump

Brazil’s Supreme Court could determine connected Thursday whether erstwhile President Jair Bolsonaro is blameworthy of masterminding a coup to enactment successful powerfulness pursuing the country’s tense 2022 statesmanlike elections.

Hailed by immoderate Brazilians arsenic “historic”, the landmark case has acceptable the full state connected edge, with tens of thousands rallying successful enactment of the populist erstwhile leader, and has besides escalated tensions betwixt Latin America’s largest federation and Washington.

Recommended Stories

• list 1 of 4Why is Brazil’s Jair Bolsonaro connected proceedings — and what’s next?
• list 2 of 4Brazil’s Supreme Court starts deliberations successful Bolsonaro coup trial
• list 3 of 4Lawyers successful Brazil taxable last connection for Bolsonaro successful coup trial
• list 4 of 4‘I americium successful nary rush’: Brazil’s Lula weighs countermeasures to Trump’s tariffs

Bolsonaro faces a five-count complaint related to attempts to signifier a coup, which helium denies. The 70-year-old claims the proceedings is simply a politically motivated effort by the authorities of President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva to forestall him from seeking different word successful the 2026 elections. US President Donald Trump, who counts Bolsonaro arsenic an ally, has echoed that statement and has tried to punish Brazil with higher commercialized tariffs.

At slightest 3 of the 5 justices of the Supreme Court sheet ruling connected the lawsuit person already voted this week. The last 2 are expected to formed their votes connected Thursday. Sentencing is apt arsenic aboriginal arsenic Friday.

Here’s what we cognize astir the trial:

Brazil’s erstwhile President Jair Bolsonaro covers his eyes astatine his location portion nether location apprehension earlier successful August [Adriano Machado/Reuters]

What is this proceedings about?

Bolsonaro, alongside 7 of his adjacent allies, faces respective charges of attempting to overturn the October 2022 statesmanlike elections aft helium mislaid to Lula, who besides served arsenic president betwixt 2003 and 2011.

Specifically, Bolsonaro faces 5 charges, including: attempting to signifier a coup, engagement successful an equipped transgression organisation, attempted convulsive abolition of the antiauthoritarian regularisation of law, and 2 much counts involving demolition of authorities spot during convulsive protests by his supporters connected January 8, 2023.

Bolsonaro’s lawyer, Celso Vilardi, said helium is not blameworthy of the charges, arguing that, though Bolsonaro assembled apical furniture and subject officials to sermon an exigency decree aimed astatine suspending the elections, the decree was yet not issued, and Bolsonaro yet ordered a modulation of powerfulness to Lula.

The erstwhile person could look up to 40 years successful jailhouse if convicted. The coup crippled complaint unsocial carries a 12-year sentence.

Others accused alongside Bolsonaro see erstwhile Defence Minister and Bolsonaro’s 2022 moving mate Walter Braga Netto, erstwhile Defence Minister Paulo Sergio Nogueira, Bolsonaro’s erstwhile aide-de-camp Mauro Cid, subject advisor Augusto Heleno Ribeiro, erstwhile Justice Minister Anderson Torres, erstwhile naval main Almir Garnier Santos, and ex-police serviceman Alexandre Ramagem.

Where is Bolsonaro now?

Since August, Bolsonaro has remained under location arrest astatine a heavy guarded gathering successful the capital, Brasilia. He is banned from societal media and has lone constricted entree to communications. In 2023, the country’s electoral committee besides barred him from moving for bureau until 2030, citing maltreatment of power.

Supporters of the president person held protests successful caller days against what they accidental is simply a witch-hunt by the Lula government. There are fears that convulsive protests could interruption retired if a blameworthy verdict is reached.

Others, though, person hailed the trial, calling it “historic”, arsenic the archetypal clip the state has attempted to clasp a person accused of attempting a coup accountable.

How person judges voted truthful far?

The Supreme Court proceeding began deliberations connected a verdict connected September 9, and is acceptable to reason connected September 12.

To scope a blameworthy verdict, 3 of the 5 judges indispensable enactment a conviction.

Three of the 5 Supreme Court justices had already voted by Thursday. Two much are expected to formed their votes connected Thursday, barring adjournments.

Justice Alexandre de Moraes, who is overseeing the ruling and is considered by Bolsonaro’s supporters to beryllium a large adversary driving the trial, was the archetypal to ballot successful favour of a condemnation connected Thursday.

Moraes, successful a five-hour-long statement, said that nether Bolsonaro’s rule, “Brazil astir returned to a dictatorship,” referring to the subject regularisation that lasted for 21 years from 1964 to 1985.

The justice said determination was grounds of a Bolsonaro-led plot, codenamed Operation Green and Yellow Dagger, to assassinate Lula, his vice president, Geraldo Alckmin, arsenic good arsenic Justice Moraes. Those efforts, helium said, culminated successful Bolsonaro supporters attacking Congress, the Presidential Palace, and the Supreme Court successful convulsive protests connected January 8, 2023.

A 2nd justice, Justice Flavio Dino, has besides voted to convict Bolsonaro.

Then, connected Wednesday, Justice Luiz Fux broke from his colleagues successful a astonishment determination and alternatively called for the lawsuit to beryllium annulled because, helium said, it had failed to travel owed process.

Fux argued that the Supreme Court had an “absolute deficiency of jurisdiction” implicit the case. He said that, due to the fact that Bolsonaro and his chap accused are nary longer governmental appointees, the lawsuit should person been heard by a little court.

He besides argued that, erstwhile the Supreme Court had go involved, the lawsuit should person been handled by the afloat sheet of 11 justices, alternatively than a five-member panel. The defence team, helium added, had not been fixed capable clip to hole its case, portion prosecutors were equipped with what helium called a “tsunami of data” amounting to “billions of pages”.

Fux, however, did regularisation against 2 allies of the erstwhile president – Mauro Cid and Netto – connected the complaint of convulsive abolition of the antiauthoritarian regularisation of law.

The 2 remaining judges indispensable present formed their votes – lone 1 much condemnation ballot is needed to seal Bolsonaro’s fate.

The 2 judges – Justice Carmen Lucia and Justice Cristiano Zanin  – were some appointed by Lula: Judge Lucia during Lula’s archetypal word arsenic president successful 2006, and Judge Zanin successful 2023. Many experts expect that they volition ballot to convict Bolsonaro. However, Judge Lucia has successful the past voted against Lula, erstwhile helium was connected proceedings betwixt 2017 and 2021 connected wealth laundering charges. Lula was yet acquitted.

People enactment successful a objection successful Praca da Republica, Sao Paulo, Brazil, September 7, 2025. Protesters demanded the apprehension of erstwhile President Jair Bolsonaro and expressed their rejection of caller policies adopted by the United States successful narration to Brazil [Isaac Fontana/EPA]

Why is Brazil divided connected the Bolsonaro case?

The Bolsonaro proceedings has deepened bitter divides betwixt the erstwhile leader’s millions of supporters and those who judge his prosecution is justified.

This past week, arsenic the Supreme Court proceedings was continuing, Bolsonaro’s supporters mobilised crossed the state successful protests. They demanded that the erstwhile person and his chap accused beryllium granted an amnesty, and accused the authorities of failing to let a just trial. Bolsonaro’s supporters are besides demanding helium beryllium allowed to tally for presidency again successful 2026, thing the erstwhile person has besides called for.

On Sunday, Bolsonaro’s wife, Michelle Bolsonaro, addressed chanting, flag-toting crowds of supporters successful Sao Paulo. In tears, she told the throng that the proceedings had brought “humiliation” to her family. The day coincided with Brazil’s September 7 Independence Day, erstwhile the state gained state from Portugal successful 1822.

Similarly, thousands person gathered successful counterprotests successful caller days, calling for Bolsonaro’s condemnation and denouncing Washington’s enactment – nether Trump – for the erstwhile leader.

In the capital, Brasilia, meanwhile, Lula’s Independence Day connection was that Brazil is “nobody’s colony” and would not judge orders from anyone.

How mightiness the US respond erstwhile a verdict is reached?

On Tuesday, White House spokesperson Karoline Leavitt suggested the US could respond powerfully – economically oregon adjacent militarily – if determination is simply a blameworthy verdict. She told a quality conference: “This is simply a precedence for the medication and the president is unafraid to usage the economical might, the subject might, of the United States to support escaped code astir the world.” She did not supply immoderate details, however.

In a response, Gleisi Hoffman, a Brazilian lawmaker and main curate of the country’s Secretariat for Institutional Relations, condemned Leavitt’s statement, saying that the US was threatening to “invade Brazil to escaped Jair Bolsonaro from prison”.

“This is utterly unacceptable,” Hoffman said successful a connection connected X. “And yet [the US] claims to beryllium defending ‘freedom of expression’. Only if it’s the state to lie, to coerce the Justice system, and to crippled a coup d’etat; those are so the crimes for which Bolsonaro and his accomplices are being tried successful owed ineligible process.”

How has the Trump medication supported Bolsonaro?

Trump has repeatedly defended Bolsonaro – and has attempted to penalise Brazil for the proceedings of his ally.

In societal media posts successful July, the US president drew parallels betwixt the Bolsonaro proceedings and his ain prosecution for alleged engagement successful an onslaught by protesters connected the US Capitol connected January 6, 2021, aft helium mislaid the 2020 US statesmanlike predetermination to Joe Biden.

Trump besides wrote a missive to President Lula, accusing him of mistreating Bolsonaro. The proceedings against Bolsonaro, helium said, was an “international disgrace”.

In July, the US Department of State sanctioned Justice de Moraes, who is starring the Supreme Court sheet for the trial. It accused him of suppressing state of look and politicising prosecutions, including that of Bolsonaro.

De Moraes has been barred from obtaining a US visa, and immoderate US properties helium whitethorn ain were ordered to beryllium confiscated. The judge’s “allies” successful the Supreme Court, arsenic good arsenic “certain household members”, person besides been barred from US visas, though the State Department did not notation names.

On August 1, Trump slapped Brazil with a 50 percent commercialized tariff, citing the charges against Bolsonaro arsenic portion of the reason.

Trump stated that the precocious tariffs were “due successful portion to Brazil’s insidious attacks connected Free Elections, and the cardinal Free Speech Rights of Americans”, saying that the verdict impacted not lone Brazilians, but Americans, too.

Trump’s planetary commercialized warfare has chiefly targeted countries that tally a ample trading surplus with the US. Brazilian imports from the US, however, already outweigh its exports; Washington had a trading surplus of $28.6bn successful goods and services with Brazil successful 2024.

Brazil’s Lula called the tariff escalation “authoritarian” but has not imposed reciprocal levies.

Could the US truly usage subject force?

Leavitt’s proposition that the US would not regularisation retired subject options against Brazil comes against the backdrop of the caller deployment of US naval forces to the Caribbean.

The US says its subject forces are successful the portion to antagonistic cause trafficking. However, the deployment comes arsenic US threats against Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro, whom US President Donald Trump’s medication has accused of being intimately linked with cause trafficking groups, person ramped up.

In aboriginal September, US forces bombed a Venezuelan boat that the Trump medication claimed – without grounds – was carrying cause traffickers ferrying narcotics bound for the US. Lula has criticised the US subject beingness successful the Caribbean Sea arsenic “a origin of tension”.