How Israel is using ‘no war, no peace’ Lebanonisation model in Gaza

A ceasefire was agreed to extremity the war, but that has not stopped Israel from attacking. On Sunday, an aerial onslaught killed 4 people. A fewer days earlier that, past Friday, different Israeli onslaught killed a antheral connected a motorbike. And connected October 17 Israeli warplanes killed astatine slightest 1 person.

None of these attacks were successful Gaza – wherever Israel has besides spent the fewer weeks since a ceasefire began connected October 10 conducting attacks, galore of them acold much deadly than those described above.

Recommended Stories

• list 1 of 3Israel strikes confederate Lebanon, sidesplitting 2 and wounding seven
• list 2 of 3‘Making history’: Mamdani to voters connected predetermination eve arsenic Trump backs Cuomo
• list 3 of 3Saudi Crown Prince MBS to sojourn Trump connected Nov 18: White House

Instead the attacks mentioned were conducted by Israel successful Lebanon, and travel a twelvemonth aft a ceasefire betwixt Israel and Hezbollah began. Yet, contempt that ceasefire, Israel has continued to onslaught sites crossed Lebanon periodically, overmuch to the choler of the Lebanese radical and government.

Israel argues that it has the close to behaviour attacks successful Lebanon it believes are indispensable until Hezbollah afloat disarms, adjacent if a ceasefire is officially successful place.

And analysts accidental the attacks successful Gaza since the latest ceasefire, which person truthful acold killed astatine slightest 236 Palestinians and wounded different 600, are grounds that Israel is implementing a argumentation of “Lebanonising” Gaza – officially ending the war, but utilizing its acold superior subject spot to springiness it the close to behaviour attacks whenever it wants for an indefinite period.

“They [Israelis] don’t privation to resoluteness the conflict,” Rob Geist Pinfold, a student of planetary information astatine King’s College London, told Al Jazeera. “War is the caller norm.”

Post-October 7 attacks reality

Before Israel’s warfare connected Gaza began connected October 7, 2023, groups similar Hamas successful Gaza and Hezbollah successful Lebanon were believed to person a grade of deterrence against Israeli aggression.

“Before October 7 [2023], determination was the content that Israel cannot person a agelong oregon prolonged war,” Pinfold said. “Its system and nine meant it was a state that wouldn’t beryllium capable to function.”

However, since the October 7 attacks by Hamas and different Palestinian groups, which killed 1,139 radical successful Israel and took much than 200 captive, Israel has embarked connected a forever war, attacking assorted targets astir the Middle East adjacent aft coming to ceasefire agreements.

The astir evident illustration has been Lebanon, wherever contempt a ceasefire statement implemented connected November 27, 2024, Israel repeatedly violated the statement by continuing its attacks.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu warned connected Sunday that the Israeli subject could property up with further enactment if the Lebanese authorities did not bash much to disarm Hezbollah, which was severely weakened successful the warfare with Israel, astir notably losing its longtime person Hassan Nasrallah.

“We volition not let Lebanon to go a renewed beforehand against us, and we volition enactment arsenic necessary,” helium said, according to a statement issued by Netanyahu’s office.

The threats person led to a consciousness of trepidation among galore successful Lebanon, who fearfulness a instrumentality to the wide attacks crossed the state anterior to the archetypal day of the ceasefire. However, for galore successful the country, peculiarly those successful the south, wherever air raids and different attacks person been persistent implicit the past year, the ceasefire has ne'er been implemented properly.

“This warfare is ever here,” Abbas Fakih, a Lebanese writer from the confederate metropolis of Nabatieh, told Al Jazeera.

“If you are from a borderline village, you cannot sojourn [it] due to the fact that you volition beryllium targeted. Anyone tin beryllium targeted astatine immoderate time.”

‘Lebanonisation’ of Gaza

This caller presumption quo allows Israel to onslaught wherever it sees acceptable astir anyplace successful the region. Israel has struck Gaza, the occupied West Bank, Lebanon, Syria, and Yemen, and has been accused of attacking Tunisia – without immoderate enactment taken against it. It was lone erstwhile Israel struck Qatar that a reddish enactment appeared to person been crossed, with the United States forcing Netanyahu to apologise.

In Lebanon specifically, Israel’s attacks person continued for a twelvemonth with sparse planetary condemnation, with those statements usually lone issued erstwhile Israel attacked the United Nations peacekeepers. Israel has besides failed to retreat its troops from astatine slightest 5 locations wrong Lebanon, contempt its committedness successful the archetypal agreement. In Gaza, immoderate analysts judge this signifier whitethorn beryllium repeating arsenic Israel looks acceptable to permission its troops deeper successful the Strip than primitively agreed upon.

But with the unusual condemnation aside, determination has been nary effort by the ceasefire’s superior enforcer – the US – oregon the planetary assemblage astatine ample to clasp Israel accountable for violating the ceasefire with Lebanon.

In the past year, Hezbollah has responded to Israel’s attacks lone connected 1 occasion. In December, Hezbollah launched an onslaught against an Israeli subject presumption arsenic a effect to aggregate ceasefire violations. There were nary casualties, but Israel responded with force, killing 11 radical successful Lebanon, including a authorities information officer.

Analysts judge that Israel present wants to recreate a akin dynamic successful Gaza, whereby Israel unilaterally sets the presumption of what constitutes a ceasefire violation. Under this dynamic, Israel tin proceed to onslaught Gaza astatine volition and immoderate effect from Hamas oregon immoderate different Palestinian radical volition effect successful an Israeli escalation.

“Netanyahu knows precise good determination is nary excuse for his aerial strikes today, but it is wide helium is trying to found a caller concern successful Gaza wherever you person nary warfare and nary peace,” Mustafa Barghouti, secretary-general of the Palestinian National Initiative, said during an interrogation with the Arab Center Washington DC connected October 29. “No afloat warfare but continuous Israeli subject attacks, precisely similar helium is doing successful Lebanon.”

Chris Osieck, a freelance researcher who has contributed to investigations from Forensic Architecture and Bellingcat connected Palestine and Israel, said the examination to Lebanon is caller but parallels tin beryllium drawn to Israel’s behaviour from further backmost successful history.

“What they person done successful Gaza during the existent iteration of the [ongoing] genocide and Lebanon is really what they’ve been doing historically successful al-Khalil and Dawaymeh, arsenic good arsenic Jerusalem,” Osieck told Al Jazeera, referring to massacres and onshore grabs from the constitution of the authorities of Israel successful 1948 onwards.

He said the Gaza genocide is continuing successful a “gradual form” done the continuation of aerial raids, portion simultaneously blocking Palestinians successful Gaza and Lebanese successful the southbound from rebuilding.

Israeli journalists adjacent to the Netanyahu authorities besides accidental this is the caller presumption quo.

“The [pre-war] Lebanonisation means your force is 1 inch from your borderline with their commando part and you spot the legitimacy oregon planetary borderline being sacred,” Amit Segal, an Israeli media property with beardown ties to Netanyahu’s government, told the Ezra Klein podcast recently. “The caller Lebanonisation says you person subject outposts behind, acold from your planetary border, and you onslaught erstwhile needed.”

The caller viewpoint of the Israelis, according to Segal, is, “you person to beryllium wherever determination is danger. This is the main acquisition of October 7”.

Is the caller presumption quo bearable?

In its caller relation arsenic determination hegemon, Israel is flexing its subject superiority implicit its neighbours. Some analysts judge it has a strategy to support its neighbours anemic and fractured to debar immoderate benignant of economical oregon subject competition.

But the question present is whether this strategy of changeless warfare is sustainable.

“Israel cannot weaponry the Middle East into a unchangeable caller order,” Marc Lynch, prof of governmental subject and planetary affairs astatine George Washington University, wrote successful a caller nonfiction for Foreign Affairs. “Regional enactment requires much than subject primacy. It besides demands immoderate grade of consent and practice from different determination powers.”

As acold arsenic Gaza is concerned, the caller strategy appears to beryllium to enactment heavy successful the Strip and person the subject acceptable to strike. That, of course, means Israel has much onshore to show but besides much country for absorption from Palestinian factions. And that could beryllium a lose-lose concern for each involved.

“This presumption quo is much bearable for Hamas than for Israel,” Pinfold said. “The occupation is that it is simply a nonstop impediment to reconstruction for the radical of Gaza.