I constitute this from Paris, a metropolis wrapped successful bluish and yellow. All astir me, Ukrainian flags bent similar motivation badges pinned to French facades.
I arrived successful this metropolis conscionable a fewer weeks agone arsenic a subsister of the genocide successful Gaza, leaving my state burning down me. I had the privilege to beryllium evacuated by the French authorities arsenic a pupil admitted to a French university.
What archetypal struck maine astir Paris, this alleged metropolis of liberty, was its curated grief, sanctioned empathy, and decorated silence.
France mourns Ukraine loudly. Gaza, connected the different hand, indispensable beryllium whispered. The Palestinian emblem cannot beryllium seen here. It is hidden, feared, criminalised. If you’re lucky, you find it painted successful graffiti, a shy declaration of solidarity hastily sprayed similar a secret.
Should I beryllium surprised?
After all, France is simply a assemblage empire that ne'er dismantled itself, but lone rebranded. From Algeria to Vietnam to Syria, France’s hands are stained with the humor of those who dared to defy it.
When France supported the Zionist question successful the 20th century, erstwhile it trained Israeli officers, erstwhile it helped militarise a settler-colonial authorities connected stolen land, it wasn’t retired of ignorance. It was retired of solidarity, achromatic solidarity, with different assemblage project.
France condemned the Russian penetration of Ukraine wrong hours. It opened its borders. It cried connected TV. It cancelled concerts and imposed sanctions. Why? Because Ukraine is white.
But erstwhile Israel flattens full neighbourhoods successful Gaza, erstwhile it bombs hospitals, starves children, cuts water, drops banned weapons, and grinds families into bony dust, France hesitates. It equivocates. It blames Hamas. It insists connected “context”. It hands Israel adjacent much weapons.
What is happening successful Gaza is not a “conflict”. It is not “complicated”. It is simply a genocide.
By authoritative statistics, much than 63,000 Palestinians person been killed since October 7, 2023; by technological estimates, the existent decease toll is successful the hundreds of thousands. Over 70 percent are women and children.
More than 80 percent of the colonisation is surviving, barely, connected 1 repast a day, often canned nutrient oregon cooked writer oregon leaves. Every day, we suffer dozens of civilians trying to get aid. Some 340 children and adults person died from starvation successful conscionable a fewer months.
Every infirmary successful the northbound has been destroyed. Children are getting amputated without anaesthesia. People with chronic diseases are dying connected a wide standard owed to the deficiency of medicine and treatment.
Aid trucks are blocked. Water desalination plants are bombed. More than 2 cardinal radical are displaced. And still, determination is silence.
United Nations experts, each large planetary quality rights organisations, thousands of ineligible and different scholars, and adjacent erstwhile Israeli officials person said that this warfare has crossed each reddish enactment of planetary law.
And yet, present successful France, we are told to little our voices. We are told that shouting “Free Palestine” mightiness beryllium anti-Semitic. The radical who question Ukrainian flags with pridefulness archer america our grief indispensable beryllium “balanced”. They rage against Russian imperialism but warrant Israeli settler colonialism. This isn’t neutrality. This is achromatic supremacy.
Gaza has go their motivation exception. Their unsighted spot. Their expendable other. The quality each newsroom twists itself to avoid.
But present is the truth: Palestine has nary army, nary jets, nary ships, nary atomic weapons. What we person is resistance. Hamas is not a authorities military. It is the result of decades of siege, occupation, apartheid, and abandonment. And portion European leaders unreserved to condemn Hamas astatine each accidental they get, they garbage to condemn the concern that birthed it. They erase our close to resist, portion glorifying the Ukrainian resistance, heaping connected it weapons and praise.
In Ukraine, Molotov cocktails are “heroism”. In Gaza, stones are “terrorism”. That’s hypocrisy. That’s the algorithm of achromatic empathy.
What is happening successful Gaza is not a warfare betwixt 2 armies. It is the wholescale demolition of an occupied radical by 1 of the astir precocious armies successful the world. It is genocide aided by Western arms, protected by Western silence, and beautified by humanitarian lies.
France wants to unreal its complicity is historical, that it ended with the extremity of ceremonial colonialism. But however bash you explicate the weapons? The diplomatic immunity? The refusal to abide by the apprehension warrant issued by the International Criminal Court for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu? The banning of pro-Palestinian protests successful Paris? The surveillance of Muslim students?
I near Gaza successful a United Nations-escorted evacuation, organised by the French consulate successful Jerusalem, my sanction selected among thousands. I was not allowed to transportation anything. No laptop. No books. No memories. Just the apparel connected my backmost and my phone.
I passed done Israeli checkpoints wherever soldiers looked astatine maine arsenic if I were not human. Four hours crossed the godforsaken felt similar 4 decades. And present I’m here, walking the boulevards of a metropolis that claims to emotion freedom, portion my radical dice for daring to privation it.
Do not archer maine this is conscionable politics. It is racism. It is hypocrisy. The genocide of my radical is being watched from balconies draped with Ukrainian flags.
I don’t privation pity. I privation accountability. I privation justice. I privation to spot Palestinian flags hanging adjacent to those of Ukraine, not arsenic competition, but arsenic truth. Because if solidarity depends connected tegument colour, borders, oregon geopolitical interest, it is not solidarity. It is supremacy.
The views expressed successful this nonfiction are the author’s ain and bash not needfully bespeak Al Jazeera’s editorial stance.

4 months ago
32








English (US) ·