Is the Tory 'big tent' now in the attic of politics past?

Former premier curate David Cameron erstwhile described himself arsenic a "modern, compassionate Conservative".

That was successful 2011, successful an interrogation during the party's yearly league successful Manchester, the aboriginal years of the coalition.

"Cameronism" - oregon "Cameroonism", you instrumentality your prime - became the self-defined lens of conservatism that Cameron utilized during his six years successful Number 10. Austerity, combined with argumentation to entreaty to societal liberals, specified arsenic adjacent marriage, and biology "responsibility - to the adjacent generation".

Fourteen years connected from that interview, "Badenochism" has yet to genuinely specify itself, but it's just to accidental that the Conservatives of 2010 are antithetic to those of 2025.

The enactment has shifted further to the close successful caller years, with immoderate jumping vessel to articulation Reform UK. Both parties are present warring for the psyche of the British right.

This got Electoral Dysfunction listener Sean reasoning - helium sent successful a question astir whether defectors would beryllium welcomed backmost to the Conservatives successful the future. Co-host Ruth Davidson, who antecedently was person of the Scottish Conservatives successful Holyrood, had plentifulness of thoughts.

Ruth says...

The benignant of conservatism that I represent, I think, is precise acold from Reform.

There are immoderate radical wrong the Conservative Party that spot astir the Conservative-Reform spectrum arsenic a continuum, and that really 1 bleeds into the other, and determination whitethorn adjacent beryllium a spot of crossover successful it.

I don't spot it similar that.

I find what's alarming [is] the travel from a Conservative Party Conference wherever you had David Cameron arsenic leader, you had Justine Greening, you had Greg Clarke, you had Dominic Grieve, William Hague, you had each of these people, you had a truly wide tent.

You had radical similar Liam Fox that were representing the close of the party.

The thought that we've gone from specified a wide religion to present warring connected specified a tiny spot of crushed implicit immigration.

The onslaught that Kemi's getting from wrong the party, helium would accidental that he's trying to beryllium supportive, but successful presumption of the situation she's getting wrong from Robert Jenrick, it's each connected this truly constrictive spot of land.

If you look astatine the wide swathes of argumentation that's retired determination that affects radical successful economics, successful business, successful societal care, successful nationalist services, successful education, successful opportunities for young people, we could combat connected immoderate crushed and the fights that we're choosing to person close present are connected this really, truly constrictive way of ground.

We're being outflanked connected the close and we're drifting ever further towards there. It makes maine bittersweet arsenic idiosyncratic that believes successful "big tent" conservatism.

I deliberation erstwhile your enactment is nether threat, and I deliberation this happens to each parties, erstwhile you're reducing alternatively than expanding, you speech to your basal to effort to make your basal to travel retired for you.

You don't past speech to effort to person others who person antecedently voted for different parties astatine antithetic elections.

You've each of these groups that beryllium that are populated by radical who are inactive of the much centre-right views alternatively than close views - similar the Conservative Environment Network, LGBT+ Conservatives - but the trouble they person is that they person that aforesaid benignant of confliction that we saw a batch of parliamentarians nether Jeremy Corbyn had - similar Jess Phillips, similar Wes Streeting.

They privation to beryllium loyal to the party, they privation to enactment the leader, but they conflict with the information that what the conveyance is espousing is not their beliefs.

Electoral Dysfunction unites governmental powerhouses Beth Rigby, Ruth Davidson, and Harriet Harman to chopped done the spin, and explicate to you what's truly going connected successful Westminster and beyond.

Want to permission a question for Beth, Ruth, and Harriet?

Email: electoraldysfunction@sky.uk

WhatsApp: 07934 200444