Reeves's cash ISA reforms 'doomed to fail', AJ Bell chief warns

Rachel Reeves's plans to curb currency ISA limits with the purpose of fuelling a question of banal marketplace investing "are doomed to fail", the brag of 1 of Britain's biggest retail concern platforms has warned.

Sky News has learnt that Michael Summersgill, main enforcement of AJ Bell, which has much than £100bn of lawsuit assets nether administration, wrote to the chancellor this week to intensify his disapproval of the reforms.

In an excoriating letter, seen by Sky News, Mr Summersgill expressed interest not lone astatine the program to chopped the currency ISA allowance from £20,000 to £12,000 successful 2027, but besides astatine the "lack of due process successful implementing the planned changes".

Money latest: The 'safest' airlines successful the world

"It is my powerfully held presumption these unwieldy proposals are doomed to neglect successful their purpose of encouraging much radical to put for the agelong word and correspond a important backward measurement for a merchandise whose occurrence has been mostly down to its comparative simplicity," Mr Summersgill wrote.

"Rushing to instrumentality these changes, which correspond a worldly involution successful the marketplace with wide-ranging consequences, without a due consultation oregon immoderate wide grounds they volition incentivise semipermanent investing represents the worst benignant of policymaking."

The forthright quality of the AJ Bell chief's disapproval underlines the heavy misgivings successful Britain's concern manufacture astir the implications of the Treasury's plans.

Sky News revealed earlier this week that a swathe of ISA providers had met officials from the Treasury and HM Revenue and Customs to outline the details of their concerns.

The authorities is drafting up elaborate anti-circumvention rules including banning transfers from stocks and shares and Innovative Finance ISAs to currency ISAs; the usage of tests to find whether an concern is eligible to beryllium held successful a stocks and shares ISA oregon is 'cash-like'; and charges connected immoderate involvement paid connected currency held successful a stocks and shares oregon Innovative Finance ISA.

However, the concern manufacture has been vocal successful informing that the regularisation changes volition summation complexity and penalise savers who are focused connected de-risking their portfolios earlier they crook 65.

There are besides concerns that a much robust attack to taxing currency balances held successful stocks and shares ISAs would severely harm the representation of ISAs arsenic a tax-free concern option.

In his missive to Ms Reeves, Mr Summersgill, whose institution serves much than 640,000 customers, said the information that the reforms were being pushed done successful narration to a merchandise astatine the centre of plans for a multimillion lb industry-funded run to beforehand retail investing was "all the much troubling".

A fig of firms, including AJ Bell, person already pulled retired of participating successful that run implicit its costs and coordination.

Mr Summersgill said determination was nary grounds that the chopped to currency ISA allowances would materially boost retail investment, adding that a survey conducted by AJ Bell recovered "the immense bulk would simply opt for currency alternatives, specified arsenic NS&I bonds, oregon prevention successful a taxable currency account".

"As we warned Treasury officials connected aggregate occasions up of the Budget, this volition harden the borderline betwixt Cash ISAs and Stocks and Shares ISAs, making it little apt existing excess funds held successful Cash ISAs volition displacement to semipermanent investing done Stocks and Shares ISAs."

"Given determination are 3 cardinal radical with astatine slightest £20,000 invested successful Cash ISAs and thing invested successful Stocks and Shares ISAs, this represents a missed accidental worthy astatine slightest £60 billion," Mr Summersgill warned.

"In the abbreviated term, radical volition rationally flock to Cash ISAs - the other of the argumentation intent - up of the allowance simplification successful April 2027."

He besides lambasted the determination to exempt those aged 65 and implicit from the changes, saying it was "a baffling property to choose" fixed that it does not correspond with the authorities pension age.

"As if this complexity wasn't enough, the anti-avoidance measures HMRC volition beryllium required to gully up to travel these reforms hazard further undermining the attractiveness of ISAs," helium wrote.

"The projected prohibition connected transfers restricts prime and flexibility, 2 cardinal benefits of ISAs, but much worrying is the volition to use a taxation complaint to currency held successful Stocks and Shares ISAs.

"The elemental information is that currency passes done Stocks and Shares ISAs each the time.

"Contributions are made successful cash, dividends are received successful cash, fees are paid successful cash, and risk-based assets person to beryllium sold to make the currency for withdrawals.

"In different words, the authorities intends to punish retail investors for utilizing the Stocks and Shares ISA the mode it was designed to beryllium utilized by levying tax."

He warned the measures "could perchance mean Stocks and Shares ISAs which let radical to clasp currency tin nary longer beryllium marketed arsenic 'tax-free', weakening the entreaty of the astir fashionable concern relationship successful the UK market".

Mr Summersgill urged the chancellor to "adopt a airy interaction attack to anti-avoidance, astatine slightest until the reforms person bedded successful and determination is an grounds ground upon which to formulate immoderate indispensable interventions".

"Any currency held successful a Stocks and Shares ISA for concern purposes should stay exempt from immoderate charge, with HMRC reserving the close to use a complaint wherever this is not deemed the case," helium wrote.

The AJ Bell main added that plans to regenerate the Lifetime ISA with a savings merchandise targeting first-time buyers lone risked adding "even much complexity to the ISA landscape".

And helium said the quality of the Treasury's consultation connected the expanse of ISA reforms "with lone a fewer months to enactment with HMRC connected the nuts and bolts means unintended consequences are acold much likely".

"Given the government's plans to chopped the Cash ISA allowance were briefed to the media up of your Mansion House connection successful July past year, determination has been much than capable clip to consult decently up of an April 2027 implementation.

"The information this hasn't happened represents a nonaccomplishment to behaviour adjacent the astir basal owed diligence earlier making a important argumentation intervention."

In the 2023-24 taxation year, savers ploughed a grounds £103bn into ISAs, with astir precisely two-thirds of that - £70bn - invested successful currency ISAs.

Earlier this week, a authorities spokesperson said: "To promote greater concern successful stocks and shares, we're processing changes to ISA rules which volition forestall circumvention of the caller little currency ISA limit.

"We're already moving intimately with manufacture and volition people wide guidance earlier the changes travel into effect."