Trump’s visa plan pushes H-1B ‘refugees’ to move elsewhere: 'it made me feel like a second-class citizen'

When Qian Zhang boarded a formation from Shanghai to Boston astatine property 18, she thought she was heading toward the "best version" of her life. It was 2009, during President Barack Obama's archetypal term, erstwhile the U.S. system was rebounding and opportunities for well-educated workers seemed plentiful.

She was bound for Dartmouth College, a apical prime for galore Chinese students, and aboriginal recovered her mode to Harvard Business School.

Qian embraced the American dream: the committedness of adjacent opportunity, a state that rewards endowment and hard work, and a spot wherever planetary citizens similar her could belong.

By her aboriginal 30s, she was a vice president astatine a planetary steadfast successful Boston, earning six figures a year. But down the glittering resume was a world defined by her migration status.

Like hundreds of thousands of overseas professionals, Qian lived connected an H-1B enactment visa — the papers that tethered her job, her quality to travel, and her full consciousness of information to the grace of her employer. "Your full beingness is tied to your job," she said. "If you suffer the job, you suffer the visa. If you suffer the visa, you suffer the country."

At first, she pushed speech her anxieties. She bought property, built friendships, and told herself she was nary antithetic from her American colleagues.

But each twelvemonth brought caller reminders: vacations chopped abbreviated to alert backmost to China for visa paperwork, discreet occupation searches due to the fact that changing employers required caller visa sponsorships, and the changeless fearfulness that 1 misstep could unravel her life. "The H-1B made maine consciousness similar a second-class citizen," she said.

In 2022, 4 months aft her promotion to vice president, Qian quit. A twelvemonth later, she packed her beingness into suitcases again. This time, she was leaving for good.

Now, the 35-year-old resides successful Portugal's capital, Lisbon, with her partner, Swiss artist-filmmaker Tobias Madison, and their newborn child. The Portuguese prima and slower pace, she says, person begun to heal the trauma of a decennary successful America, wherever each promotion, abrogation and romanticist entanglement felt shadowed by the aforesaid fear: what happens if her visa disappears?

Chasing the imagination — and the visa

The H-1B visa fundamentally shaped her vocation path, Qian said. "Only a fistful of sectors adjacent sponsor it — finance, tech, consulting, instrumentality and medicine. You don't person galore options," she said.

She had done respective stints successful Boston, from strategy consulting to concern improvement astatine a tech firm, earlier rising to go a vice president astatine a user products company.

"When the system is strong, you whitethorn person a accidental to vie connected an adjacent footing with different occupation seekers. But erstwhile the system is bad, you're the past pick, if you're picked astatine all."

Her anxiousness deepened during President Donald Trump's archetypal term, erstwhile visa processing delays and audits rose. Even Qian, who seemed to embody the benignant of high-skilled idiosyncratic the U.S. claimed to prize, felt vulnerable. "I had a struggle astatine enactment erstwhile and thought, if I get fired, I mightiness person to permission immediately," she recalled. "I was truthful anxious I really crashed my car."

The state was nary longer the 1 she entered successful 2009, she said. Reading the comments nether quality articles astir migration was sobering. "The America I went to believed successful openness, successful welcoming talent," she said. "The America I near was divided, suspicious, anxious."

Her disillusionment echoed a broader inclination of slowing planetary pupil enrollment successful the U.S. successful caller years.

"America utilized to beryllium the dream," she said. "Now radical similar maine look elsewhere."

A caller chapter

Lisbon, with its tiled streets and Atlantic sunsets, is simply a satellite distant from Boston and New York. Qian and her spouse are renovating a farmhouse successful the Portuguese countryside. She is penning a publication and exploring originative projects. Life is slower, cheaper, freer, she said.

Portugal has been a hotspot for integer nomads, luring overseas distant workers with affable visa policies, a amended prime of life, and a little outgo of living.

Her visa process successful Portugal, she said, was "the easiest of my life." When she pressed her lawyer for what could spell wrong, the lawyer reassured her: "Don't worry, we are not the U.S."

Her years successful America gave her fiscal information — she graduated erstwhile the system was strong, saved responsibly and invested prudently. That cushion allowed her to commencement over. "I was lucky," she said. "I caught the close wave."

Still, she is ambivalent astir the state that shaped her adulthood. "I utilized to spot everything done the lens of the U.S.," she said. "Now I spot it's not the halfway of the world."

She hopes the U.S. tin rediscover the openness that erstwhile drew her in. "I privation America to go the America we believed in," she said. "Open. Confident. Free. Not this fearful, closed-off mentation of itself."

Until then, she said, much radical similar her volition support leaving. "Maybe," she added with a tiny smile, "America needs america much than we request America."

Are you acceptable to bargain a house? Take Smarter by CNBC Make It's caller online course How to Buy Your First Home. Expert instructors volition assistance you measurement the outgo of renting vs. buying, financially prepare, and confidently navigate each measurement of the process—from owe basics to closing the deal. Sign up today and usage coupon codification EARLYBIRD for an introductory discount of 30% disconnected $97 (+taxes and fees) done July 15, 2025.

Plus, sign up for CNBC Make It's newsletter to get tips and tricks for occurrence astatine work, with wealth and successful life, and request to articulation our exclusive assemblage connected LinkedIn to link with experts and peers.