Why a Bollywood spy film sparked a political storm in India and Pakistan

4 weeks ago 18

New Delhi, India – A recently released Bollywood spy thriller is winning praise and raising eyebrows successful adjacent measurement successful India and Pakistan, implicit its retelling of bitter tensions betwixt the South Asian neighbours.

Sunk successful a sepia tone, Dhurandhar, which was released successful cinemas past week, is simply a 3.5-hour-long cross-border governmental spy play that takes cinemagoers connected a convulsive and bloody travel done a satellite of gangsters and quality agents acceptable against the backdrop of India-Pakistan tensions. It comes conscionable months aft hostilities broke retired betwixt the 2 countries successful May, pursuing a rebel onslaught connected a fashionable tourer spot successful Pahalgam, successful Indian-administered Kashmir, which India blamed Pakistan for. Islamabad has denied relation successful the attack.

Since the partition of India to make Pakistan successful 1947, the nuclear-armed neighbours person fought 4 wars, three of them implicit the disputed portion of Kashmir.

The movie stars the fashionable histrion Ranveer Singh, who plays an Indian spy who infiltrates networks of “gangsters and terrorists” successful Karachi, Pakistan. Critics of the movie reason that its storyline is laced with ultra-nationalist governmental tropes and that it misrepresents history, an emerging inclination successful Bollywood, they say.

What is the latest Bollywood blockbuster about?

Directed by Aditya Dhar, the movie dramatises a covert section from the annals of Indian intelligence. The communicative centres connected a high-stakes, cross-border ngo carried retired by India’s Research and Analysis Wing (R&AW), and focuses connected 1 operative who conducts operations connected force ungraded to neutralise threats to Indian nationalist security.

The movie features a heavyweight ensemble formed led by Singh, who plays the gritty tract cause tasked with dismantling a “terror” web from the inside. He is pitted against a formidable antagonist played by Sanjay Dutt, representing the Pakistani establishment, and gangsters specified arsenic 1 portrayed by Akshaye Khanna, portion actors including R Madhavan represent cardinal quality officers and strategists who orchestrate analyzable geopolitical manoeuvering from New Delhi.

Structurally, the screenplay follows a classical cat-and-mouse trajectory.

Beneath its high-octane acceptable pieces, the movie has sparked an aggravated statement among critics and audiences implicit the mentation of humanities events and immoderate cardinal figures.

Why is the movie truthful arguable successful Pakistan?

Despite the longstanding geopolitical tensions betwixt the 2 countries, India’s Bollywood films stay fashionable successful Pakistan.

Depicting Pakistan arsenic the eventual force of India has been a fashionable taxable retold for years, successful antithetic ways, particularly successful Bollywood’s spy thrillers, however. In this case, the portrayal of Pakistan’s large coastal city, Karachi, and peculiarly 1 of its oldest and astir densely populated neighbourhoods, Lyari, has drawn beardown criticism.

“The practice successful the movie is wholly based connected fantasy. It doesn’t look similar Karachi.  It does not correspond the metropolis accurately astatine all,” Nida Kirmani, an subordinate prof of sociology astatine Lahore University of Management Sciences, told Al Jazeera.

Kirmani, who has produced a documentary connected the interaction of pack unit successful Lyari of her own, said that similar different megacities successful the world, “Karachi had periods of unit that person been peculiarly intense.”

However, “reducing the metropolis to unit is 1 of the large problems successful the film, on with the information the movie gets everything astir Karachi – from its infrastructure, culture, and connection – wrong”, she added.

Meanwhile, a subordinate of the Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) has taken ineligible enactment successful a Karachi tribunal alleging the unauthorised usage of images of the precocious erstwhile premier minister, Benazir Bhutto, who was assassinated successful 2007, and protesting against the film’s portrayal of the party’s leaders arsenic supporters of “terrorists”.

Critics, including Kirmani, accidental the movie besides bizarrely casts gangs from Lyari into geopolitical tensions with India, erstwhile they person lone ever operated locally.

Kirmani said the makers of the movie person cherry-picked humanities figures and utilized them wholly retired of context, “trying to framework them wrong this precise Indian nationalistic narrative”.

Mayank Shekhar, a movie professional based successful Mumbai, pointed retired that the movie “has been performed, written, directed by those who haven’t ever stepped ft successful Karachi, and possibly ne'er will”.

“So, ne'er caput this particulate vessel for a metropolis that, by and large, seems wholly bereft of a azygous modern building, and looks mostly bombed-out, betwixt aggregate ghettos,” Shekhar said.

He added that this is besides successful enactment with however Hollywood “shows the brownish Third World successful enactment with a definite sepia tone, similar with Extraction, acceptable successful Dhaka, Bangladesh”.

How has the movie been received successful India?

Dhurandhar has been a immense commercialized occurrence successful India and among the Indian diaspora. However, it has not escaped disapproval entirely.

The household of a decorated Indian Army officer, Major Mohit Sharma, filed a petition successful Delhi High Court to halt the merchandise of the film, which, they claim, has exploited his beingness and enactment without their consent.

The makers of the movie contradict this and assertion it is wholly a enactment of fiction.

Nonetheless, the film’s storyline is accompanied by real-time intercepted audio recordings of attacks connected Indian ungraded and quality footage, movie critics and analysts say.

People seen successful beforehand of a movie theatre that is screening the movie Kashmir files that

Is this an emerging signifier successful Bollywood films?

Shekhar told Al Jazeera that focusing connected a deliberately loud, seemingly over-the-top, hyper-masculine hero’s travel is not a caller genre successful Bollywood. “There’s a inclination to intellectualise the trend, arsenic we did with the ‘angry young man’ movies of the 1970s,” helium said, referring to the formative years of Bollywood.

In caller years, mainstream accumulation houses successful India have, however, favoured storylines that represent minorities successful antagonistic airy and align with the policies of the Hindu nationalist authorities of Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Kirmani told Al Jazeera that this often means “reducing Muslims crossed India’s borders and wrong arsenic ‘terrorists’, which further marginalises Muslims successful India culturally”.

“Unfortunately, radical gravitate towards these kinds of hypernationalistic narratives, and the manager is cashing successful connected this,” she told Al Jazeera.

Modi himself lavished praise connected a caller movie called Article 370, for what helium said was its “correct information” astir the removal of the law proviso that granted peculiar autonomous presumption to the authorities of Jammu and Kashmir successful 2019. Critics, however, called the movie “propaganda” and said the movie had distorted facts.

Another Bollywood movie Kerala Story released successful 2023 was accused of falsifying facts. Prime Minister Modi praised the film, but critics said it tried to vilify Muslims and demonise the confederate Kerala authorities known for its progressive politics.

In the lawsuit of Dhurandhar, immoderate critics person faced online harassment.

One reappraisal by The Hollywood Reporter’s India YouTube channel, by professional Anupama Chopra, was taken down aft outrage from fans of the film.

Went looking for Anupama Chopra’s Dhurandhar review? It’s gone. The Hollywood Reporter India softly made the video private.

For context, The Hollywood Reporter India was launched by RPSG Lifestyle Media, portion of the RP-Sanjiv Goenka Group, which besides owns Saregama –…

— newslaundry (@newslaundry) December 9, 2025

India’s Film Critics Guild has condemned “coordinated abuse, idiosyncratic attacks connected idiosyncratic critics, and organised attempts to discredit their nonrecreational integrity”, successful a statement.

“More concerningly, determination person been attempts to tamper with existing reviews, power editorial positions, and transportation publications to change oregon dilute their stance,” the radical noted.

Read Entire Article