3 days ago
7
The International Commission of Jurists has filed a ceremonial petition for an probe into International Court of Justice (ICJ) Vice President Julia Sebutinde implicit her caller comments astir Israel.
The commission, which advocates for quality rights and regularisation of instrumentality worldwide, argued that Sebutinde’s presumption connected Israel reveals a bias that brings judicial integrity into question. Sebutinde, who is 1 of the 17 judges successful the ICJ genocide lawsuit against Israel, besides faces different critics.
Here is much astir Sebutinde, what she said and wherefore she is facing criticism:
Who is Julia Sebutinde?
Sebutinde is 1 of the judges proceeding South Africa’s genocide lawsuit against Israel. These are the aforesaid judges who voted connected provisional measures to support Palestinians successful Gaza successful January 2024.
Sebutinde, 71, is simply a Ugandan justice who is presently serving her 2nd word astatine the ICJ, wherever she has sat since March 2012. She is the archetypal African pistillate appointed to the The Hague-based ICJ. She was elected arsenic the vice president of the apical United Nations tribunal successful February 2024.
According to the Institute for African Women successful Law, Sebutinde was raised by a household of humble means during Uganda’s independency movement. She attended Lake Victoria Primary School successful Entebbe, Uganda, and Gayaza High School, a girls boarding school. She earned her instrumentality grade from Makerere University successful 1977.
In 1990, Sebutinde obtained a maestro of laws grade with favoritism from the University of Edinburgh successful Scotland, which besides awarded her an honorary doctorate successful 2009 for her ineligible achievements.
Before joining the ICJ, she served arsenic a justice connected the Special Court for Sierra Leone opening successful 2007.
What was Sebutinde’s dissenting sentiment connected Palestine?
In a lawsuit filed successful December 2023, South Africa alleged that Israel was committing genocide successful Gaza during the warfare that began connected October 7, 2023. South Africa argued that Israel’s actions successful Palestine were genocidal due to the fact that they intended to “bring astir the demolition of a important portion of the Palestinian national, radical and ethnical group”.
On January 26, 2024, the ICJ issued a ruling connected a fig of interim steps. It ordered six provisional measures, telling Israel to:
- Take enactment to forestall acts of genocide
- Prevent incitement to perpetrate genocide
- Let much humanitarian assistance into Gaza
- Protect and support grounds related to accusations of genocide nether the Genocide Convention.
- Allow fact-finding missions
- Report to the tribunal connected measures taken
Fifteen of the 17 judges voted for each the exigency measures to beryllium enactment successful place. An Israeli justice voted for 2 of the six measures to beryllium implemented. Sebutinde was the lone justice to ballot against each the measures.
In her dissenting opinion, Sebutinde wrote: “In my respectful dissenting sentiment the quality betwixt the State of Israel and the radical of Palestine is fundamentally and historically a governmental one. It is not a ineligible quality susceptible to judicial colony by the Court.”
She besides stated that South Africa did not show that Israel’s alleged actions were “committed with the indispensable genocidal intent, and that arsenic a result, they are susceptible of falling wrong the scope of the Genocide Convention”.
The court’s last verdict is inactive awaited. Last year, the International Criminal Court issued apprehension warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and erstwhile Defence Minister Yoav Gallant for warfare crimes.
Several rights organisations person called Israeli actions successful Gaza genocide. Israel has besides been accused of warfare crimes and crimes against humanity during astir 23 months of war, which person killed much than 62,000 Palestinians.
Who has called for Sebutinde to beryllium investigated and why?
The Geneva-based International Commission of Jurists, made up of 60 judges and lawyers, wrote a letter connected Friday to ICJ President Yuji Iwasawa requesting the investigation. It cited remarks Sebutinde made connected August 10 astatine Watoto Church successful Kampala, Uganda, wherever she said: “The Lord is counting connected maine to basal connected the broadside of Israel.”
The missive added that Principle 2 of the UN Basic Principles connected the Independence of the Judiciary affirms that “the judiciary shall determine matters earlier them impartially, connected the ground of facts and successful accordance with the law, without immoderate … improper influences … from immoderate 4th and for immoderate reason.”
Sebutinde’s remarks are “inconsistent with these principles”, said the letter, signed by the commission’s secretary-general, Santiago Canton.
Canton closed the missive by urging Iwasawa to behaviour an probe into the allegations against Sebutinde and instrumentality remedial actions if the allegations are recovered to beryllium true.
While an probe takes place, Canton requested Iwasawa region Sebutinde from further proceedings successful the ICJ lawsuit filed by South Africa.
The authorities of Uganda distanced itself from her dissenting opinion.
“Justice Sebutinde’s ruling astatine the International Court of Justice does not correspond the Government of Uganda’s presumption connected the concern successful Palestine,” Adonia Ayebare, Uganda’s ambassador to the UN, posted connected X successful January past year.
Could Sebutinde beryllium removed? How?
The ICJ statute says members of the ICJ cannot beryllium dismissed unless different members unanimously hold that they nary longer fulfil the required conditions.
If a justice is dismissed, the ICJ registrar makes a ceremonial notification to the UN secretary-general and this notification renders the presumption vacant.
The ICJ website adds that this has ne'er happened.
The website sets standards for its judges, stating: “Judges indispensable beryllium elected from among persons of precocious motivation character, who person the qualifications required successful their respective countries for assignment to the highest judicial offices, oregon are jurisconsults of recognised competence successful planetary law.”
It besides adds that “once elected, a Member of the Court is simply a delegate neither of the authorities of his ain state nor of that of immoderate different State.”
The ICJ statute adds that earlier assuming duties astatine the ICJ, members indispensable marque a solemn declaration that they volition workout their powers impartially and conscientiously.
Who are the judges successful the case?
The ICJ has 15 judges elected for nine-year presumption by the UN General Assembly and the Security Council.
For the lawsuit that South Africa brought against Israel, an Israeli justice and a South African justice joined the bench. From South Africa, elder retired Judge Dikgang Moseneke came connected committee portion erstwhile Israeli Supreme Court Chief Justice Aharon Barak joined the lawsuit from Israel.
(Al Jazeera)
English (US) ·