Narrative war: Who killed thousands during Iran’s nationwide protests?

Tehran, Iran – Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei has acknowledged that “several thousands” of Iranians person been killed since protests started successful precocious December among shopkeepers successful downtown Tehran, earlier gradually spreading to large and tiny cities.

That confirmation is antithetic due to the fact that Khamenei has typically avoided commenting connected decease tolls during erstwhile protests successful Iran implicit the years.

Recommended Stories

• list 1 of 3Sudan’s radical endure ‘horror and hell’ successful war, says UN rights chief
• list 2 of 3‘Everything is bad’: Fear and anxiousness grip Iranians overseas amid protests
• list 3 of 3Just similar Venezuela, Iran, too, is expendable for Russia

But determination are stark contrasts successful the narratives provided by the Iranian state, foreign-based opposition, and United States President Donald Trump implicit precisely what has happened during the unrest, and what could beryllium coming next.

What bash we cognize for certain?

The protests started implicit economic grievances successful concern and commercialized districts of the superior metropolis connected December 28, and morphed into nationwide expressions of choler and vexation astatine the governmental constitution implicit the days that followed.

The nights of January 8 and January 9 were by acold the deadliest, according to authorities officials and media, arsenic good arsenic foreign-based outlets and eyewitness accounts connected the ground.

Abbas Masjedi Arani, the caput of Iran’s aesculapian examiner authority, told authorities media that galore of the casualties were changeable successful the thorax oregon the caput from adjacent scope oregon from rooftops with the purpose of inflicting mortal wounds, portion others were stabbed to death.

State outlets said astir protesters were young Iranians, galore successful their 20s.

Iranian authorities person afloat chopped disconnected entree connected the nighttime of January 8, arsenic good arsenic mobile communications, truthful it was not adjacent imaginable to telephone rescue services successful cases of emergency.

The unprecedented net blackout began to gradually standard backmost connected Sunday aft astir 2 weeks, but astir of the country’s 90-million-strong population stay successful limbo amid uncertainty implicit what the aboriginal could hold.

Local calls, SMS substance messages and outgoing planetary telephone calls person been restored implicit caller days. A section intranet that offers immoderate constricted services is operational.

The protests connected the streets person present mostly died down, with thousands of heavy equipped information forces mounting up patrols and checkpoints crossed the country, particularly astatine flashpoints similar the Grand Bazaar successful Tehran.

The organisation of videos of the protests extracurricular of Iran has been uncommon amid the integer blackout, with lone a number of Iranians capable to permission the state oregon link to Starlink outer net that bypasses the government’s net restrictions.

What does the authorities say?

Iranian officials, from governmental to subject and judicial leaders, person emphasised connected a regular ground that the US and Israel person been down the protests, accusing the overseas powers of arming and backing the opposition.

Khamenei, Iran’s 86-year-old ultimate leader, said that Trump was a “criminal” for straight involving himself successful the unrest galore times.

According to Iranian government, equipped and trained “terrorists”, not authorities forces, were straight liable for the killings of thousands during the protests. They assertion that radical acting connected behalf of the US and Israel changeable and stabbed radical to derail peaceful demonstrations.

Judiciary officials person stressed that those who took portion successful “riots” volition look swift punishments without immoderate mercy shown. The Supreme Court and the wide prosecutor’s bureau announced connected Sunday that they had formed a associated workgroup to expedite protest-related cases.

What are foreign-based monitors saying?

Foreign-based monitors and Iranians overseas who are opposed to the Iranian constitution support that authorities forces killed protesters successful immense numbers.

The latest figures by the widely-cited Human Rights Activists News Agency (HRANA), which is based successful the US, accidental much than 3,300 deaths person been confirmed, and implicit 4,300 others are being investigated.

The organisation besides says 2,107 radical person been severely wounded, and much than 24,000 arrested.

The Reuters quality bureau connected Sunday cited an unnamed Iranian authoritative successful the portion arsenic saying astatine slightest 5,000 radical person been killed, including astir 500 information personnel. Most deaths were reportedly recorded successful the Kurdish-majority areas of Iran successful the northwest.

Al Jazeera is incapable to independently verify these figures.

Foreign-based outlets person besides reported that Iranian authorities request alleged “bullet money” from the families of protesters killed by information forces successful bid to let their burial, oregon request that families motion documents saying they were members of the Basij paramilitary unit of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) and not protesters. Iranian officials person rejected some claims.

What are the US and Israel saying?

US and Israeli officials person been openly touting the imaginable for toppling the theocratic enactment successful Tehran implicit caller months, including during the 12-day warfare successful June.

At the tallness of the protests, Trump urged Iranians to stay successful the streets, alleging “help is connected the way”, earlier expressing “great respect” for the Iranian enactment based connected a assertion that planned executions for much than 800 governmental prisoners were halted.

The US president “speaks a batch of nonsense”, Tehran authoritative Ali Salehi said connected Saturday successful absorption to the claim, adding that “our effect volition beryllium deterring and quick”.

But Trump has not stopped his comments, and connected Saturday called for the extremity of Khamenei’s 37-year regularisation and branded the Iranian person a “sick man”.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has refrained from straight commenting connected the protests. Israeli nationalist broadcaster Kan reported that Netanyahu ordered his officials to halt giving interviews connected the taxable aft Heritage Minister Amichai Eliyahu said past week that Israeli operatives are progressive successful Iran “right now” arsenic they were during the 12-day war.